Clonmel Borough District has voted to extinguish the public right of way at East Lane, which links Gladstone Street and Mitchel Street, after business and property owners asked for the laneway to be closed.

The November meeting was told that owners had sought the closure because of persistent anti-social behaviour, including drug-related activity, vandalism and damage to property. The meeting was also told that a business owner in the area had suffered a serious eye injury after an incident in the laneway.

Cllr Pat English was the only councillor to oppose the decision. He said the public right of way had existed for hundreds of years and that anti-social behaviour was a policing matter, not a reason to close the lane. He also said there was a lack of Garda resources in the town, and warned that if historic lanes were closed, few would be left.

Mayor Cllr Siobhán Ambrose said she was not in favour of closing laneways in the town in general, but was supporting this proposal because of the difficulties facing business and property owners there. She said the situation had become intolerable for those owners, and that their personal safety was under threat. Cllr Ambrose said there was constant drug dealing in the laneway, that a firework had been thrown, and that people had been climbing onto and running across roofs. She also said a business owner had suffered permanent damage to an eye after an incident in the lane, and that a garda could not stand in the laneway around the clock.

District engineer Gillian Flynn told the meeting that property owners had approached her for a solution. She said other measures, including efforts to increase footfall, had not stopped the anti-social behaviour. A survey of property owners had found they were all in favour of closing the lane, she said. Automated locking gates are to be installed at either end, with access limited to authorised users.

Cllr Richie Molloy supported the closure and said it could be reviewed in a few years, noting that another lane in the town had been closed and later reopened. Cllr John Fitzgerald said this laneway was not used as a regular thoroughfare and was harbouring anti-social activity. He said closing it would move that activity onto the streets, where gardaí would be better able to see it. Cllr Tom Acheson asked whether the public used the laneway regularly, and said he presumed people who needed access would still be able to get it.

Cllr Ambrose proposed that the public right of way be extinguished, and Cllr Fitzgerald seconded the motion. Cllr English was the only dissenting voice.